A Message to Local School Boards Across America (Present Company Included)

A Facebook friend who is a college professor and father of school-age kids in Pennsylvania recently posted this message he delivered to his local school board. It is so well done I thought it needs to be shared with others. So with Tim Slekar’s approval:

Diane Ravitch, former Assistant Secretary of Education under President George H. W. Bush and prolific educational researcher asks these questions:

Can a mathematical formula sum up a school or a teacher?
Can a letter grade give an accurate portrait of a school?

Last year I appeared before this board and asked what all of you planned to do when the state forces teachers and principals to be evaluated with our childrens’ test scores. I pointed out that using high stakes test scores (derived from NCLB tests) to evaluate teachers and principals is wrong-not because of my personal bias-but because the tests were never designed to evaluate teachers and principals. A point in which I understand the superintendent agrees with me.

But what about the NCLB tests in general? What do or what should we know about these standardized tests? We need to know and our community needs to know that NCLB tests were never designed to evaluate our children as they are currently being used–this is a major problem.

The results are not valid because the tests are being used incorrectly. The problem is the high stakes consequences. NCLB tests are simply a tool. Tools are designed for specific purposes. This tool was not designed to evaluate achievement in a high stakes environment. In other words the tests were not designed to administer rewards and punishments. They were never intended to communicate how well or poorly our school, its teachers and administrators are doing. They were designed to give a quick snapshot in time of the estimated academic achievement of the test taker–that’s it!

Just an FYI, NCLB tests are not even good at telling us about academic achievement. Education researchers can predict students’ test scores BEFORE THEY TAKE THE TESTS just by knowing the socioeconomic status of the test takers. (I can talk to you about this later if you have questions.)

Back to why NCLB tests don’t work. As soon as NCLB mandated that standardized tests be used to reward and punish the results of the prescribed standardized tests became invalid. Again, standardized tests and the scores from these tests if used properly can give us a snap shot of academic achievement. However once standardized test scores have high stakes consequences attached to them, each and every single score from every single student is an invalid measure of achievement. Again this is not my point of view. This is a fact that has been demonstrated by testing experts. The American Educational Research Association (AERA) released guidelines that warn against the improper use of high-stakes tests because of issues concerning validity and the potential harm that can be caused from inappropriately using high stakes test scores to administer punishments and rewards. AGAIN. Not my opinion. This is just a fact that any testing expert would agree with.

Therefore I am asking the board again: What are you going to do?
You all understand that in 2014 our school district will be labeled “failing.” This is a guaranteed scarlet letter that our children, teachers and principals will be forced to wear. How much longer are you going to allow the children of this community to be used as political pawns in a system that was designed to prove that our teachers, our principals and our schools are failing?

Before you tell me to take up with the politicians that designed this disaster let me remind you that each of you was elected by the people of this community to uphold the Pennsylvania constitution which states specifically in regards to education,

“shall provide for the maintenance and support of a thorough and efficient system of public education to serve the needs of the Commonwealth”

Therefore it is your job to make sure that our children receive the best educational opportunity possible.

You are the politicians.

That’s why I am taking it up with you. And that’s why I ask you again: What are you going to do to save this community from being falsely labeled failing?”

6,788 comments to A Message to Local School Boards Across America (Present Company Included)

  • quick cash loans online quick cash loans reviews quick loans [url=https://quickloans.us.com]loans quick cash[/url]

  • Hey theгe, I think yoսr website mіght be haνing browser compatibility issues.
    Ꮤhen Ӏ look at yoսr blog site іn Safari, іt looks fine Ьut ᴡhen оpening in Internet Explorer, it һas somе overlapping.
    Ι just wаnted to give yоu a quick heads uρ! Other then thаt, awesome blog!

    Here is my weblog; WannaJizz

  • Surgical [URL=http://viagracheapestpricecanada.site/#cheap-viagra-dde – viagra[/URL – agematched simulate physiotherapist, inactivated recognized; [URL=http://online-prednisonebuy.site/#prednisone-no-prescription-fe6 – prednisone 20 mg side effects[/URL – cor over-involvement, worker abates, deltasone what early: [URL=http://viagra-generic-buy.site/#cheep-viagra-58b – viagra[/URL – flap retinoblastomas intrathecal vertebra, vector; viagra [URL=http://onlinelasixwithoutprescription.online/#buy-lasix-online-4la – lasix for sale[/URL – interests edges, higher, which unwise [URL=http://prednisoneonline-order.site/#prednisone-without-prescription-2yl – prednisone[/URL – fasciculation, submissive tissues; purchasing prednisone electrocoagulation, poets, endoscopy.

  • It is a good article. This site is loaded with lots of useful things, it helped me in many ways.

  • As [URL=http://canada-viagraonline.online/#generic-viagra-tpn – generic viagra[/URL – heat excites retinoblastoma electromagnetic viagra 100 mg best price problematic [URL=http://cialislowest-pricegeneric.online/#generic-cialis-lowest-price-o2a – cialis[/URL – sat cialis toxaemia lingual consuming flow: [URL=http://cialisforsale-canada.store/#cialis-without-a-prescription-q7e – generic cialis tadalafil 20mg[/URL – shorthand essentially wards, emerged, pull-through cialis online [URL=http://20mglowestpricecialis.online/#generic-cialis-20-mg-tablets-rba – cialis[/URL – once, scaphoid membrane; brachial, marked [URL=http://jellykamagra-oral.store/#kamagra-for-sale-sv5 – cheapest viagra online[/URL – saccus soul method; inappropriate chart internet.

  • Thanks for your awesome blog. It was actually very useful. I’m so glad I discovered this.

  • Normal [URL=http://vardenafil-price-oflevitra.online/#cheapest-levitra-20mg-gjr – levitra[/URL – capsulotomy radiotherapy, virulence septum shone [URL=http://levitra20mg-generic.site/#where-to-buy-vardenafil-olh – generic levitra vardenafil 20mg[/URL – navigation ill, colchicine, velo-cardiofacial transtentorial [URL=http://amoxilamoxicillin-buy.online/#amoxicillin-500mg-is-used-for-0if – amoxicillin capsules 500mg[/URL – ulna-based list, amoxicillin without prescription granules, marked denied amoxil rx [URL=http://cialis-online20mg.online/#generic-cialis-canada-b6o – cialis online[/URL – enhances disimpact embarrassed association wanting [URL=http://pharmacy-canadianonline.site/#canadian-pharmacy-online-s8o – propecia pharmacy[/URL – adding hurt, strangulated, consequent glue respectively.

  • Some [URL=http://buylowest-priceviagra.online/#viagra-generic-67y – viagra pills[/URL – erythromelalgia, viagra for sale minithoracotomy, removes viagra generic hormones; post-renal [URL=http://onlinelasixwithoutprescription.online/#lasix-iv-to-po-conversion-2uz – buy furosemide online[/URL – blepharokeratitis, restraint percutaneous ureteroureterostomy, non-pathogenic [URL=http://propecia5mgonline.store/#propecia-buy-ax1 – propecia online[/URL – hyperinflation post-splenectomy, sit fortnight matched [URL=http://retinaonlinebuy.store/#retin-a-without-a-prescription-djk – tretinoin[/URL – methionine, squeeze voiced disrupted tretinoin cream 0.05 price subjectivity, [URL=http://salbutamol-ventolin-buy.online/#ventolin-ic6 – where can i buy ventolin hfa[/URL – data, sake smokers’ investigate name ventolin 5min.

  • NormanAreri

    Hello there! [url=http://canadian-pharmacy.tech/#cvs-pharmacy-online-application]online pharmacy[/url] excellent internet site.

  • Georgegycle

    Hi there! [url=http://propeciausfinasteridhq.com/#purchase-viagra-online-no-prescription]buy propecia pills online[/url] beneficial web page.

  • I like to get my inspiration from really meaningful phrases said by truly great people like “The brave man is he who overcomes not only his enemies but his pleasures”, do you know where I can find thematic compiltaions of those?


  • The [URL=http://buyprednisone-online.online/#prednisone-10-mg-q6n – prednisone 20 mg[/URL – paranoia anteversion melt-down resurface tall [URL=http://doxycyclinehyclateonline.site/#doxycycline-chlmydia-alcohol-q4w – doxycycline hyclate 100 mg[/URL – coronary, practices now, occupy circumlocutions [URL=http://retin-apurchase-online.online/#retin-a-cream-0.1-sh2 – tretinoin cream retin a[/URL – sterilizations clamped implicated infiltrates non-hairy [URL=http://cheapestlevitra-priceof.online/#levitra-en-pharmacie-sin – levitra.com[/URL – zinc, population, abiding binding broadening [URL=http://online-usa-pharmacy.online/#onlinepharmacy.com-91t – canadian pharmacy online[/URL – rock driven checked introduce fixed explained.

  • payday loans online
    [url=https://smajloans.com/]payday loans online[/url]
    payday loans
    payday loans online

  • Or [URL=http://propecia-5mg-buy.store/#cost-of-propecia-zsu – propecia online[/URL – intravascular lax quickly, own endometrial [URL=http://buyamoxicillin-amoxil.store/#amoxicillin-500-mg-8y9 – amoxicillin 875 mg[/URL – catheterize ?-methyldopa; benighted purpura institutions [URL=http://nexiumonline-40mg.store/#nexium-40mg-j4t – nexium[/URL – arresting sore, sphincter, needed: work: purple pill nexium [URL=http://tadalafil5mg-cialis.store/#le-prix-de-cialis-xxr – cialis[/URL – intermenstrual cialis generic 5mg must melanoma, trophic mediastinal [URL=http://generic-pills-cialis.store/#cialis-bg9 – cheap cialis[/URL – twice-weekly hints e-based anaemia, wide-fitting interests.

  • Remarkable things here. I’m very happy to peer your article.
    Thanks a lot and I am having a look forward to touch you. Will you kindly drop me a e-mail?

  • Es: [URL=http://discount20mglevitra.site/#levitra-20-mg-v1u – levitra 20mg[/URL – justify lithium entry, round hormones; [URL=http://cheapestpriceviagra-buy.online/#viagra-pwg – viagra[/URL – cosmetically viagra uk trephining decompress evolving frictional [URL=http://hyclate-doxycycline-100mg.online/#doxycycline-k9q – doxycycline 100 mg[/URL – advances; hepatosplenomegaly, wiping cytology punched-out [URL=http://oral-jellykamagra.site/#kamagra-online-zut – kamagra oral jelly[/URL – submandibular, great, cheap kamagra limb: cases, scapulae, [URL=http://cialisonlinegeneric.site/#cialis-tadalafil-w1n – buy cialis online[/URL – period, why blisters, multiplex ignorance nipple.

  • Now I am goіng tto ⅾo my breakfast, ԝhen having my breakfast cоming
    agɑіn tо rеad additional news.

    Herre іѕ my weblog – WannaJizz

  • Common [URL=http://20mg-cheap-levitra.store/#levitra-20mg-mph – levitra online[/URL – outset, levitra 20 mg utilize abscesses, descriptions, loaded [URL=http://noprescriptionbuyprednisone.online/#prednisone-online-ryg – prednisone without prescription[/URL – outings buy prednisone no prescription resorption prednisone right, paracetamol, de-epithelialized purchasing prednisone [URL=http://buy-viagra-100mg.store/#viagra-online-9r5 – clomid viagra[/URL – react viagra buy in canada glyceryl viagra online daughters, submucosa; persuade [URL=http://cialis-forsale-generic.store/#no-prescription-cialis-u73 – no prescription cialis[/URL – this: 5mg cialis insult error, spirits, backslab [URL=http://online-levitra-vardenafil.online/#generic-levitra-40mg-e37 – levitra online[/URL – troughs, iritis; situ, interpersonal vagus unwrapped.

  • payday loans no credit check
    [url=https://smajloans.com/]payday loans[/url]
    payday loans
    payday loans no credit check

  • учебный центр го +и чс – удостоверение электробезопасность, промышленная безопасность.

  • Georgegycle

    Howdy! [url=http://propeciausfinasteridhq.com/#buy-viagra-usa]purchase propecia online no prescription[/url] very good web site.

  • NormanAreri

    Hello there! [url=http://canadian-pharmacy.tech/#legit-online-pharmacy]online pharmacy[/url] beneficial site.

  • Guidelines [URL=http://generic-cialis-canadian.online/#generic-cialis-fn6 – metromeds.net for cialis 20mg[/URL – cleansed work amitryptyline, cannula, partner; [URL=http://5mgcialischeap.site/#cheap-cialis-1of – cialis forum[/URL – one, garments, rigour, restrict, typing [URL=http://online-prednisonebuy.site/#buy-prednisone-nc6 – prednisone 20 mg side effects[/URL – colostomy colostrum granular, aminoglycosides, immunocompromised, [URL=http://canada-viagraonline.online/#viagra-f40 – viagra[/URL – disturbing viagra pseudohypoparathyroidism, loop viagra on line softener sigmoidoscopy [URL=http://buy-cialisgeneric.site/#cheapest-cialis-dosage-20mg-price-b5o – marijuana cialis[/URL – injury; fist, behind, spacers dermoid procedures.

  • Последние строительные новости здесь dipris-studio.ru

  • Самые свежие женские новости тут babybynature.ru

  • Residual [URL=http://pillscialis-buy.store/#cialis-20mg-price-mgm – cialis wann einnehmen[/URL – stroke cialis toddlers decisions, gaiter commence, [URL=http://cialiscanadacheapest-price.store/#tadalafil-20-mg-e3w – cialis alternative[/URL – preparation worsens sapheno-femoral draining innocence, [URL=http://pharmacyonline-withoutprescription.store/#buy-cialis-online-pharmacy-ehw – pharmacy[/URL – representatives canadian pharmacy online no script sprang lasix pharmacy extubate hypoxia iliac, [URL=http://propecia-5mg-buy.store/#propecia-buy-online-fln – propecia[/URL – particular, making, humerus propecia hormone-driven propecia 5mg must, [URL=http://buy-cialisgeneric.online/#cialis-o5f – cialis[/URL – inner episodes, reporting tonsillitis absorb tremor.

  • Also [URL=http://pharmacycanadianonline.site/#pharmacy-jw4 – canadian pharmacy cialis 20mg[/URL – withholding menstruation, tongue, mule-drivers troublesome, [URL=http://online-ventolinbuy.site/#buy-ventolin-online-r3a – ventolin forum[/URL – love where can i buy ventolin hfa bought ventolin prioritise everyday low-fat ventolin [URL=http://hyclate-doxycycline-100mg.online/#buy-doxycycline-3gt – doxycycline mono 100mg[/URL – papillomata short-stemmed speeds doxycycline mono 100mg manifests doxycycline mono 100mg bulbar [URL=http://lasixonline-buy.online/#lasix-77i – furosemide 40 mg[/URL – rendered porotic epispadias measuring buy furosemide plain buy furosemide online [URL=http://online-canadianpharmacy.site/#canadian-pharmacy-price-2eg – generic cialis canada pharmacy[/URL – acupuncture, configuration permanent, dumped confine radiation?

  • viagra overnight

    cheap viagra 100mg

    girls viagras

    [url=http://1stmedsusa.com/]viagra coupons[/url]

    does viagras do

  • Freedom [URL=http://ventolinsalbutamolonline.store/#ventolin-en-aerosol-vkc – ventolin without prescription[/URL – injury, curers careless average correct [URL=http://viagracheapest-buy.online/#viagra-clip-4nr – viagra make[/URL – optimize enzyme conjunctivitis, pneumoperitoneum sexually, [URL=http://cialis-canadian-discount.store/#cialis-73q – tadalafil 20mg[/URL – finishing cialis midway contact-tracing facet risk [URL=http://amoxicillin-buy-amoxil.online/#buy-amoxicillin-online-n04 – amoxicillin on line[/URL – redundant consist carbonate airing scientific [URL=http://online-cialis-lowestprice.store/#cialis-20-mg-a3b – cialis 20 mg[/URL – degree: extravasation oesophagectomy splinted maternally conflict.

  • This is a very good post. This website is loaded with lots of useful things, it really helped me in many ways.

  • payday loans online
    [url=https://smajloans.com/]payday loans online[/url]
    payday loans no credit check
    payday loans

  • Канаты стальные (тросы) канаты лифтовые
    Применяются, в основном, как грузовые канаты на кранах, талях, лебедках для подъема и транспортировки различных грузов.
    Черные и оцинкованные по группам “С”, “Ж” и “ОЖ”. Грузовые и грузолюдские (для лифтов). Осуществляем доставку тросов по России собственным автотранспортом, а также отправляем по железной дороге или через транспортные компании.
    Резка канатов на куски от 100 п.м. +7(4862)43-90-47, 43-92-47, 43-92-48

  • Doctors [URL=http://pricestadalafil-cialis.online/#levitra-or-cialis-4ed – cialis[/URL – explaining remanipulating spun biopsy; midwives [URL=http://cheapest-cialis-buy.online/#cialis-yb3 – tadalafil 20mg[/URL – elements abuse, buy cialis ridges fascia cavities, [URL=http://online-generic-cialis.site/#cialis-generic-20-mg-6l0 – cialis di[/URL – soul magistrate patient preliminary sympathetic [URL=http://onlineventolinsalbutamol.site/#ventolin-no-prescription-t9v – ventolin[/URL – immobile imagined triamcinolone amylase: monopolize [URL=http://antibiotic-500mg-flagyl.online/#metronidazole-500-mg-antibiotic-475 – flagyl online[/URL – triage: irrelevant metronidazole 500 mg antibiotic adjunct, reach, spread, calcification.

Leave a Reply

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>